Meet New Books

Books Like...

A beautifully written, atmospheric mystery blending classic whodunit vibes with rich character exploration. Perfect for fans of thoughtful, cozy mysteries and Louise Penny’s signature charm.

If you liked A Rule Against Murder, here are the top 17 books to read next:
(We also have 100 recommendations for the series: Chief Inspector Armand Gamache)

Page 1
Showing 1 - 10 of 17 
  1. #1

    The Twelve Days of Murder by Andreina Cordani
    Save:

    The Twelve Days of Murder by Andreina Cordani is a twisty thriller set in a snow-covered Scottish mansion, where a group of unlikable characters from a university murder mystery club reunite for one last event. This Agatha Christie-esque tale unfolds in a dual timeline, allowing readers to experience the past and present from different points of view while piecing together the mystery of who is behind the murders. The clever integration of the Twelve Days of Christmas theme adds a festive twist to the suspenseful narrative, keeping readers engaged with numerous red herrings and unexpected plot twists.

    The writing style is characterized by an atmospheric and suspenseful tone, immersing readers in the chilling setting and the complex dynamics among the characters. Although some felt the multitude of characters was initially confusing and detracted from their connection to the story, the overall execution is seen as well-crafted and enjoyable. The book offers a satisfying mystery with a dash of gore, perfect for those looking for a dark yet festive read during the holiday season.

    November 2023
    290 pages

  2. #2

    The Christmas Murder Game by Alexandra Benedict
    Save:

    A twist-filled, cozy Christmas mystery with mind-bending puzzles - great fun for fans of holiday whodunits, but may stretch believability for some.

    After the death of the family matriarch, eight cousins and in laws converge on the Armitage family's Yorkshire mansion, Endgame House, for one last round of the traditional Christmas Game. The stakes are high, as Aunt Liliana's will dictates that the game's winner will become the heir to Endgame House itself. As the weather outside worsens, the various resentments, alliances and shared histories of the protagonists immediately become clear as the cousins reconnect and settle into Endgame. For our heroine, Lily Armitage the Christmas Game provides not only the opportunity to inherit Endgame, but also to solve her mother's mysterious death 21 years previously.

    The Christmas Murder Game is an entertaining seasonally themed read, combining the long tradition of the snowed-in country house murder mystery, echoes of the board game Cluedo, and the crime fiction trope of the deadly treasure hunt. Alexandra Benedict's narrative is structured around the traditional twelve days of Christmas, with a clue in the form of a sonnet riddle being provided at some point on each day. Puzzle lovers like myself will delight in the liberal use of anagrams, literary and musical allusions, and word association with which the participants, and by extension the reader, must contend.

    September 2021
    305 pages

  3. #3
    The Appeal
    Book 1 in the series:Fairway Players

    The Appeal - Fairway Players by Janice Hallett
    Save:

    A sharp and original mystery that invites you to play detective, The Appeal is a must-try for fans of unconventional storytelling and twisty, character-driven puzzles. Just don’t expect a traditional narrative or quick answers!

    'The Appeal' by Janice Hallett is a murder mystery novel that unfolds through emails, text messages, and other correspondence within a small town amateur dramatics society. The story revolves around the amateur production of a play and a fundraising campaign for a little girl's medical treatment, all while keeping the reader guessing about the motives and relationships of the characters involved. The format of the book, told entirely through written correspondence, provides a unique and engaging way to reveal the intricate web of social dynamics and secrets within the group.

    The author, Janice Hallett, skillfully crafts a narrative that allows readers to piece together the events and motivations behind the mystery through the characters' own words. The book offers a fresh and original approach to storytelling, drawing readers into the lives of the characters through their emails and messages, creating a sense of voyeurism and intrigue as the plot unfolds.

    This letter is one of recommendation. Samantha Greenwood worked as a volunteer nurse for Médecins Sans Frontières from September 2010 through January 2018. She was a valuable and popular member of the...
    January 2021
    454 pages

  4. #4
    Death of a Gossip
    Book 1 in the series:Hamish Macbeth

    Death of a Gossip - Hamish Macbeth by M.C. Beaton
    Save:

    A light, cozy slice of small-town Scottish crime - perfect for fans of gentle mysteries who don't mind a few quirks. Not Beaton's strongest work, but a pleasant series starter if you're in the mood for comfort over complexity.

    "Death of a Gossip" in the Hamish Macbeth series by M.C. Beaton follows Constable Hamish Macbeth as he investigates the murder of Lady Jane Winters, a notorious gossip columnist, during a fishing school in Lochdubh, Scotland. The story unfolds with quirky characters, a cozy mystery setting, and a unique detective style portrayed by Hamish Macbeth, which sets the stage for a classic whodunit with a Scottish twist. The writing style is described as light-hearted and engaging, capturing the essence of a British cozy mystery with elements of humor and traditional murder mystery tropes.

    ‘I hate the start of the week,’ said John Cartwright fretfully. ‘Beginning with a new group. It’s rather like going on stage. Then I always feel I have to apologize for being English. People who trave...
    1985
    219 pages

  5. #5

    One by One by Ruth Ware
    Save:

    A fast-paced, atmospheric thriller that’s perfect for fans of modern whodunits and wintry locked-room mysteries - expect suspense, a fresh setting, and classic Ruth Ware tension, even if some plot beats feel familiar.

    One by One by Ruth Ware is a fast-paced thriller set in a French chalet where an avalanche and blizzard cut off the inhabitants from the rest of the mountain, leading to a series of mysterious deaths. The story is told from alternating points of view, creating a suspenseful atmosphere reminiscent of Agatha Christie's works. The plot revolves around a group of co-workers from a music networking app company called Snoop who are trapped in the chalet, testing their relationships and revealing hidden motives as the body count rises.

    I keep my earbuds shoved into my ears on the minibus from Geneva Airport. I ignore Topher’s hopeful looks and Eva, glancing over her shoulder at me. It helps, somehow. It helps to shut out the voices...
    September 2020
    405 pages

  6. #6

    The Hunting Party by Lucy Foley
    Save:

    A chilly, tension-filled, and thoroughly engaging locked-room mystery that's perfect for fans of atmospheric thrillers - just beware, these friends are as frosty as their Highlands hideaway!

    A group of friends from Oxford and their significant others spend the New Year's holiday in a secluded Lodge in Scotland. One ends up dead, sparking suspicions among the group. The narrative toggles between the days leading up to the murder and the aftermath, gradually revealing the victim and the killer. The characters are complex, harboring resentments, secrets, and conflicts, adding layers to the locked room mystery set in a snowbound hunting lodge. The author, Lucy Foley, crafts a suspenseful tale with a cast of unlikeable characters, keeping readers guessing until the end.

    As he comes closer I see that his features are frozen with shock. I know this look. I have seen it before. This is the expression of someone who has witnessed something horrific, beyond the bounds of...
    2018
    361 pages

  7. #7
    The Word Is Murder
    Book 1 in the series:Hawthorne

    The Word Is Murder - Hawthorne by Anthony Horowitz
    Save:

    A smart, inventive detective mystery with a meta twist - perfect for fans of classic whodunits and clever storytelling, though the self-referential style may not be to everyone’s taste.

    'The Word Is Murder' by Anthony Horowitz is a cleverly crafted murder mystery that follows the investigation of the murder of a woman, Diana Cowper, who is found dead in her home just hours after arranging her own funeral. The story centers around a unique partnership between a disgraced ex-detective, Daniel Hawthorne, and author Anthony Horowitz, who is roped in to write a true crime book about the case. Horowitz skillfully blends fact and fiction, inserting himself as a character in the narrative, leading to a compelling mix of real events and imaginative storytelling. As the duo delves into the case, they uncover a web of motives, suspects, and twists that keep the reader guessing until the surprising solution is revealed.

    The book weaves together multiple storylines, including a double murder case involving Diana Cowper and her son, adding layers of complexity to the central mystery. Horowitz's writing style incorporates elements of metafiction, humor, and intricate plotting to create a captivating narrative that blurs the lines between reality and fiction. With a rich cast of characters, red herrings, and gradual elimination of suspects, 'The Word Is Murder' offers a riveting exploration of crime-solving, character dynamics, and the interplay between the author's own life and the fictional world he creates.

    Just after eleven o’clock on a bright spring morning, the sort of day when the sunshine is almost white and promises a warmth that it doesn’t quite deliver, Diana Cowper crossed the Fulham Road and we...
    August 2017
    400 pages

  8. #8

    The Black Echo - Harry Bosch Universe by Michael Connelly
    Save:

    A rock-solid, moody detective novel that launches a beloved series - perfect for lovers of twisty, character-focused mysteries, but may not suit those wanting light, feel-good fare.

    The Black Echo revolves around LAPD detective Harry Bosch who is drawn into a murder investigation involving a fellow Vietnam veteran. As Bosch delves deeper into the case, he uncovers a complex plot tied to a bank robbery, all while navigating challenging relationships with his superiors and an FBI partner. The book is praised for its impressive police procedural elements, well-developed characters, and gritty details that immerse readers into the heart of Los Angeles and Bosch's past in Vietnam.

    The smoke carried up from the Cahuenga Pass and flattened beneath a layer of cool crossing air. From where Harry Bosch watched, the smoke looked like a gray anvil rising up the pass. The late afternoo...
    1992
    475 pages

  9. #9

    The Turn of the Key by Ruth Ware
    Save:

    A deliciously creepy, twist-packed thriller that will keep you guessing–perfect for fans of Gothic suspense and smart, modern mysteries, even if the ending leaves a few questions lingering.

    'The Turn of the Key' by Ruth Ware is a suspenseful mystery thriller that follows the story of Rowan Caine, a nanny accused of murdering one of the children she was caring for. The book is written in a unique format, primarily through letters, which creates an atmospheric and suspenseful narrative. As Rowan navigates her new job at a secluded smart house in Scotland, she uncovers disturbing secrets and mysterious occurrences, leading to a chilling and twisty plot that keeps readers on the edge of their seats.

    The story is filled with creepy and spooky elements, blending modern technology with a Victorian setting to enhance the suspense and mystery. Readers are taken on a journey of unraveling the truth behind the events at Heatherbrae House, with unexpected twists and turns that culminate in a shocking and ambiguous ending, leaving unanswered questions and a sense of unease.

    I started writing to you last night, Mr. Wrexham, and when I woke up this morning and looked at the crumpled pages covered with my pleading scrawl, my first instinct was to rip them up and start again...
    August 2019
    374 pages

  10. #10

    The Death of Mrs. Westaway by Ruth Ware
    Save:

    A wonderfully atmospheric, gothic-tinged family mystery that leans into secrets, guilt, and inheritance drama - especially recommended for fans of classic whodunits and moody, character-driven suspense!

    The Death of Mrs. Westaway by Ruth Ware follows the story of Harriet Westaway, also known as Hal, who receives a letter about an inheritance from her grandmother, Hester Westaway, a woman she never knew existed. Desperate for money, Hal decides to attend the funeral and reading of the will, only to uncover a web of family secrets and mysteries that she must navigate. As she delves deeper into the Westaway family, Hal finds herself in danger and must untangle the truth about her parentage amidst a backdrop of isolation, deception, and dark revelations.

    Ruth Ware's writing in The Death of Mrs. Westaway is described as engrossing, gothic, and suspenseful, reminiscent of classics like Rebecca. The book combines elements of family turmoil, long-buried secrets, and a brooding Cornish mansion, all wrapped up in a twisty mystery that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. With a compelling protagonist, shifty characters, and a questionable will, Ware's storytelling style draws readers in and immerses them in a modern take on the classic gothic mystery genre.

    The girl leaned, rather than walked, into the wind, clutching the damp package of fish and chips grimly under one arm even as the gale plucked at the paper, trying to unravel the parcel and send the c...
    May 2018
    444 pages

Page 1 of 2Next Page