'Shadows Fall' by Simon R. Green is a book that follows the story of James Hart, a character who is considered by some readers as lacking depth and compelling qualities. The plot revolves around magical elements, intricate concepts, and well-defined villains versus heroes. However, the book is criticized for its execution, with opinions mentioning inconsistencies in the storyline, unsatisfying endings, and abrupt conclusions. Despite the potential for exploring a diverse range of characters and settings, some readers feel that the book falls short in fully realizing its narrative and character development.

Characters:

While some supporting characters are engaging, the main character is often seen as underdeveloped, leading to a lack of connection for readers.

Writing/Prose:

The writing style is characterized by intricate storytelling and clever elements, though it can feel awkward and is designed to provoke thought.

Plot/Storyline:

The plot is notable for its abrupt ending and the exploration of a city where forgotten ideas exist, incorporating themes of good and evil.

Setting:

The setting adds an interesting backdrop of a city for forgotten ideas, blending suburban themes with fantasy elements.

Pacing:

Pacing varies throughout the book, with engaging beginnings but a rushed, unsatisfying conclusion.

It was Carnival in Shadows Fall once again. A time of feasting and revelry, parades and fairs, conjurors and costumes and marvels. At the edge of town, tents and stalls had appeared all over Lumpkin H...

Notes:

The ending of Shadows Fall is described as abrupt and unsatisfying by multiple readers.

The story features characters that are animated versions of forgotten public figures from history and popular culture.

The mix of genres includes fantasy elements and horror themes, making it a unique read.

Some readers have commented that this book challenges their thoughts on deeper subjects and moral dilemmas.

One character, James Hart, is seen as less compelling and lacks depth compared to other characters.

Fans of Simon R. Green appreciate returning characters from his other works, like Bruin Bear and The Sea Goat.

Readers noted the book's clever weaving of plot elements and references to well-known fictional characters.

There are mentions of distinct themes, such as the struggle between good and evil and the influence of power.

Shadows Fall had been referenced in Green's prior Nightside series, generating anticipation for its release.

Some review comments suggest a desire for a longer story to explore the characters and setting in more depth.

Sensitive Topics/Content Warnings

Content warnings include themes of violence and potentially sensitive topics related to heroism and death.

From The Publisher:

Considered by the author to be his finest work yet, this is a novel of realistic detail, heartfelt emotion, and dazzling imagination that builds a world readers won't want to leave and spins a tale they won't want to end. In a town of amazing magicks, where the real and the imagined live side by side and the Faerie of legend know the automatons of the future, Time sees all-but even he cannot escape the prophecy of James Hart's return, which can only mean the death of Shadows Fall.

Ratings (1)

Incredible (1)

Reader Stats (1):

Read It (1)

What can you read after
Shadows Fall?

Meet New Books is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a way for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products and services on amazon.com and its subsidiaries.
When you click the Amazon link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commision, at no cost to you.

Shadows Fall

Simon R. Green