Meet New Books
Book Cover

The Dumb House

Save:
Find on Amazon

Who Would Like This Book:

If you appreciate psychological explorations and beautifully poetic - even haunting - prose, this book delivers in a big way. Fans of unsettling and thought-provoking fiction, particularly those interested in philosophy, questions about humanity, and the role of language in shaping our sense of self, will find this a captivating (if chilling) read. Think along the lines of "Perfume" or "American Psycho," but with a philosophical edge.

Who May Not Like This Book:

This is not a book for the faint-hearted. The subject matter is deeply disturbing, with a protagonist who is not only unsympathetic but downright despicable. If you prefer hopeful stories, clear resolutions, or need to connect emotionally with your narrator, you might want to give this one a miss. Some readers also found the pacing uneven and felt certain sections rambled or dwelled too much on disturbing details.

Gorgeously written and deeply unsettling, "The Dumb House" is a dark, philosophical, and unforgettable story that will appeal to lovers of literary horror and boundary-pushing fiction - but it's definitely not for everyone.

About:

'The Dumb House' by John Burnside is a dark and disturbing novel that explores the themes of language, human nature, and the complexities of the soul. The story follows Luke, a reclusive man conducting experiments to see if children can develop language without exposure to it. The narrative delves into Luke's twisted character, his unusual upbringing, and his depraved activities, all while questioning the essence of communication and its role in shaping thoughts and souls. The book is written in a dreamy and poetic style, drawing readers into a chilling yet compelling tale of moral incomprehensibility.

Characters:

The characters are unsettling, particularly the protagonist Luke, whose lack of empathy and disturbing actions drive the narrative's horror.

Writing/Prose:

The writing style is poetic and chilling, weaving a melodic narrative that highlights the unsettling themes within.

Plot/Storyline:

The plot centers on a dark experiment regarding language and the soul, with a focus on the twisted reasons behind the protagonist's actions and his disturbing upbringing.

Setting:

The setting is isolating and dark, reflecting the themes of entrapment and the complexity of human understanding.

Pacing:

The pacing varies, with some sections feeling slow and introspective, while others maintain a gripping, disturbing momentum.
No one could say it was my choice to kill the twins, any more than it was my decision to bring them into the world. Each of these events was an inevitability, one thread in the fabric of what might be...

Notes:

The Dumb House was published in 1997 and is considered a Vintage Classic.
The story is narrated in the first person by a reclusive bachelor named Luke.
The central theme revolves around the idea of whether children raised without language can develop thoughts and possess a soul.
Luke conducts an experiment where he raises children in isolation without exposing them to language.
The narrative features Luke's unusual upbringing and his depraved behavior towards women.
The book is noted for its dark and poetic writing style.
A foreword discusses Akbar the Great's historical experiment on language acquisition using mute caregivers.
Luke's character is portrayed as despicable and morally incomprehensible, leading to readers feeling unsettled after reading.
The book is divided into three parts, each focusing on different relationships in Luke's life.
The novel ends ambiguously, reflecting on the continuation of life despite its horrors.
Readers have found the philosophical themes about human nature and language thought-provoking yet disturbing.
The book has drawn comparisons to American Psycho in its exploration of a twisted mind.
Some readers have described it as a mix between a chilling psychological thriller and a poetic exploration of language.
The opening line immediately captivates readers, hinting at the unsettling nature of the story.
The book's tone has been described as both lyrical and cold, contributing to its disturbing impact.
Many readers recommend it for those interested in dark themes and philosophical inquiries about language and communication.

Sensitive Topics/Content Warnings

Content warnings include graphic violence, child abuse, themes of neglect, and moral depravity.

From The Publisher:

As a child, Luke's mother often tells him the story of the Dumb House, an experiment on newborn babies raised in silence, designed to test the innateness of language. As Luke grows up, his interest in language and the delicate balance of life and death leads to amateur dissections of small animals - tiny hearts revealed still pumping, as life trickles away. But as an adult, following the death of his mother, Luke's obsession deepens, resulting in a haunting and bizarre experiment on Luke's own children.

1997
213 pages

Ratings (1)

Loved It (1)

Reader Stats (7):

Read It (2)
Want To Read (5)

About the Author:

John Burnside is amongst the most acclaimed writers of his generation. His novels, short stories, poetry and memoirs have won numerous awards, including the Geoffrey Faber Memorial prize, the Whitbread Poetry Award, the Encore Award and the Saltire Scottish Book of the Year. In 2011, Black Cat Bone won both the Forward and the T.S. Eliot Prizes for poetry. A judge for the Booker prize in 2015, he is a professor in the School of English at Saint Andrews University.

 
Meet New Books is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a way for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products and services on amazon.com and its subsidiaries.
When you click the Amazon link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commision, at no cost to you.