Meet New Books
Book Cover

The Fanatic

Save:
Find on Amazon

'The Fanatic' by James Robertson is a novel that intertwines two timelines, one set in the late 20th century and the other in the mid-17th century Scotland. The story follows Andrew Carlin, who becomes involved in a ghost tour in Edinburgh and starts to uncover the history of Major Weir and James Mitchel, two figures plagued by personal demons and persecution. The book delves into themes of religious persecution, historical events, and parallels between past and present, all wrapped in Robertson's descriptive and authentic Scottish writing style.

Characters:

The characters are complex, reflecting historical figures and their burdens, often viewed as misunderstood or repellent.

Writing/Prose:

The prose is detailed and descriptive, with a strong emphasis on historical authenticity, but the extensive use of dialect can hinder readability.

Plot/Storyline:

The plot interweaves the historical narrative of Major Weir and modern-day Andrew Carlin, highlighting their personal struggles and the parallels in their lives.

Setting:

The setting spans historical and modern Edinburgh, emphasizing Scotland's tumultuous past and present.

Pacing:

The pacing varies, with some sections engaging while others can feel slow and disjointed.
Hugh Hardie needed a ghost: one that would appear down a half-lit close at ten o’clock at night, and have people jumping out of their skins. He also needed a drink. He was seated at a table in Dawson’...

Notes:

The story is set in Edinburgh, Scotland, and features a ghost tour job.
Andrew Carlin plays the ghost of Major Weir, a convicted devil-worshiper from the 17th century.
Major Weir was executed for crimes including incest and bestiality.
The novel explores the parallels between characters from the 17th century and modern times.
James Mitchel, a co-conspirator of Major Weir, is another key historical figure in the story.
Mitchel was tortured and imprisoned on Bass Rock after a failed assassination attempt.
The narrative intertwines two timelines: one from the 17th century and one from the present day.
Many readers found the use of Scots dialect challenging, making the text hard to read.
The novel discusses themes of religious persecution and human rights abuses in Scottish history.
The ending does not provide a clear moral conclusion, leaving some loose ends.
Despite its challenges, the book is noted for its detailed historical accuracy and beautiful language.

Sensitive Topics/Content Warnings

Content warnings include themes of violence, historical persecution, and the use of dialect that may be challenging for some readers.

From The Publisher:

The impressive debut from an exciting new Scottish voice - a stunning novel about history, identity and redemption. A no. 2 best-seller in Scotland.

It is Spring 1997 and Hugh Hardie needs a ghost for his Tours of Old Edinburgh. Andrew Carlin is the perfect candidate. So, with cape, stick and a plastic rat, Carlin is paid to pretend to be the spirit of Colonel Weir and to scare the tourists. But who is Colonel Weir, executed for witchcraft in 1670.

In his research, Carlin is drawn into the past, in particular to James Mitchel, the fanatic and co-congregationist of Weir's, who was tried in 1676 for the attempted assassination of the Archbishop of St Andrews, James Sharp.

Through the story of two moments in history, 'The Fanatic' is an extraordinary history of Scotland. It is also the story of betrayals, witch hunts, Puritan exiles, stolen meetings, lost memories, smuggled journeys and talking mirrors which will confirm James Robertson as a distinctive and original Scottish writer.

Reader Stats (1):

Not Interested (1)
 
Meet New Books is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a way for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products and services on amazon.com and its subsidiaries.
When you click the Amazon link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commision, at no cost to you.