Carry On

I'm a bit mad at myself for not picking it upp sooner and judged it over basically nothing. I didn't think the series would be for me at all. Thought it would lack in entertaining and intense moment just because it was a sort of play on "fanfic" but I missed a completely great story because of nonsens. I'm so eager to get the next book out from my library and continue on with it

Carry On is a work that blends fantasy and romance, offering a provocative and engaging take on the conventions of the "chosen one" archetype. Inspired by sagas like Harry Potter, the book subverts the traditional view of the hero in a creative way, standing out for its multifaceted narrative told from multiple perspectives. This choice provides the reader with a rich and complex view of the magical universe, making the story even more intriguing.

The strongest aspect of the book is, without a doubt, its character development and the progression of the central romance. Rainbow Rowell, already known for creating displaced and emotionally fragile characters, brings that same talent to this story. Simon Snow, the protagonist, is captivating precisely because of his contradictions: he is a clumsy, confused, and often lost hero. His tendency to live according to the expectations of others, without questioning them, is evident throughout his narrative. His relationship with his sexuality is presented in an instinctive and natural way, while his impulsive actions—always driven by courage or the need to fight—conceal a latent fragility. This dynamic is further symbolized by his connection with the Insidious Humdrum, the literal embodiment of a great void, which reinforces Simon's internal complexities.

Baz, on the other hand, is a fascinating counterpoint. His sarcasm and apparent arrogance hide a deep sense of self-deprecation, rooted in his history of loss and his condition as a vampire—something that directly opposes everything his mother, a vampire hunter, stood for. This duality makes Baz a deeply emotional character, captivating readers with his layers and contradictions. Other characters, such as Penelope and Agatha, add some more depth to the narrative, each bringing their own emotional complexities and unique perspectives on the magical world.

The romance between Simon and Baz is the heart of the book, and Rowell develops it with delicacy and authenticity. The dynamic of rivalry and attraction is treated in a genuine way, creating a relationship that oscillates between comedic, emotional, and profoundly intimate moments. It’s a romance that charms by being both awkward and heartfelt, reflecting the insecurities and growth of the characters.

The magical universe of Carry On is another noteworthy aspect. While not deeply developed, the idea of magic rooted in language and culture is original and brings a fresh perspective to the genre. The figure of the Mage, as an ambiguous villain, adds interesting layers to the narrative: he is not the typical classic antagonist but rather a powerful and emotionally unstable—even unhinged—leader whose actions carry political and social implications. The choice to gradually unveil the secrets of the universe through secondary characters—often without Simon and Baz being fully aware—creates an interesting dynamic but also leaves gaps that could have been more thoroughly explored.

Overall, Carry On is a book that combines action, emotion, and a good dose of humor, captivating readers with its deeply human characters and its charming romance. While the magical universe has room for further expansion, Rainbow Rowell delivers a story that wins hearts with its balance of emotional complexity and narrative lightness. It’s an engaging and memorable read, especially for those seeking a romance that goes beyond clichés.

First DNF of the new year. I got about 100 pages in (and now regret buying this book). I'm not sure whether it's just too "meta" for me, if it has anything to do with the criticisms leveled at Harry Potter, I'm not in the mood for this type of writing, or the book seems to capitalize on its pseudo is/is not relation to Harry Potter. I read

Fangirl before reading

Carry On, so I was familiar with the characters, though I don't ship Harry/Draco. Therefore, anything mimicking that kinda gave me the heebie-jeebies.

Maybe Harry Potter holds too high a place in my heart. Maybe I need to look at the very real critiques, legitimate ones, facing the series. I don't know. But it still feels to me like Rowell is capitalizing on HP and it doesn't sit well with me.

Rainbow Rowell finishes the story she started in

Fangirl by writing the fanfiction featured in that story. I have to say, the only reason this got 4 stars instead of 5 is because in

Fangirl, Rowell showed the sublimation of Baz and Simon's desire for each other through Agatha so, so well. That kind of dynamic is often running under the text of love triangles, but Rowell highlighted it in a hilarious and touching way.

I also love how this is Harry Potter grown up. Not everyone is a hero. Not even the Chosen Ones are heroes, necessarily. We don't know who the Chosen Ones are. And why does everyone have to sacrifice themselves to the cause? They don't. They wouldn't, because it isn't human nature. A great coming of age story for everyone in the novel.

The interactions between Simon amd Baz were very funny and cute.

I hate that they were gay.